This week, after the BBC’s Children In Need appeal raised £39m, the ‘Big British Castle’ is the topic of Simon Alexander’s diary entry
First of all, congratulations of Owain Wyn Evans, the guy who got his big break when he drummed along to the BBC News theme and has been waking up Radio 2 listeners between 4-6.30am for the last few years. His reward was cycling hundreds of miles across the four nations This Place covers, raising a quite astonishing amount of money, over £3.5m. He became the latest presenter to accept the hardest job in broadcasting: trying not to break down in tears on live radio while the lactic acid builds up.
Sara Cox did brilliantly with her running last year for the same cause, raising £11m, and in March Greg James ended up in Edinburgh to raise over £4.5m for Comic Relief. In the interests of fairness to the commercial radio sector, Global and Bauer do a lot for charity too: the former have their Make Some Noise campaign, while the latter have Cash For Kids. I haven’t looked it up but I expect even ad-funded radio needs to have a charitable element enforced upon them by statute; even so, they do not get three hours of tele every March and November, as Comic Relief and Children In Need do. That’s because Heart, Absolute, Capital, LBC and Magic aren’t the national broadcaster.
Next year, 2027, is a big year for what the comedian Adam Buxton calls the Big British Castle. Auntie Beeb has already celebrated its/her centenary, although these days there is definitely a feeling of the Black Knight from Monty Python about it/her (I’ll go for it). How many more times can it cry ‘Tis but a flesh wound!’ as it gets its limbs hacked off and its organs pulled out? In the last few months alone the BBC has already lost, or the loss has been announced of, Ski Sunday, Live At The Apollo, The World Tonight and much of its foreign bureaux. I’m curious to see what happens to the BBC News button on Sounds; is it a precursor to an amalgamation of their speech radio offerings?
‘I’ve got an idea,’ Vish said to me the other day. ‘Why not bring together streaming and podcasting into one amazing medium? You can call it radio. It’ll be brilliant! You hear a song and then someone talks, then you hear another song, and so on until the news.’
‘It’ll never catch on, will it, Em?’
‘Move on, Vish. The world has changed and audio is unbundled.’
‘Yes, but what does that mean for the BBC, which has been doing bundled radio for a century?’
‘Youtube,’ said my policy adviser. ‘They’ve put cameras in radio studios now, so that podcasting is a visual medium, like what happened when TV replaced radio in the 1950s. I think it’s because people want to see other people’s emotions, like when we didn’t have conversation mediated through screens.’
'Profound,’ I said, asking Vish to make some coffee. ‘What about people with faces for radio?’
‘Like politicians? Showbiz for the ugly?’
‘They all need a glow-up,’ Vish said as he pottered over to the machine. ‘And that reminds me, Al, can you read over the script for this Children In Need herogram?’
The BBC has followed the herd and pivoted to Youtube, as you would expect when its Director General (really? A DG? In 2026? It sounds like a figure from the Imperial Raj!) was parachuted in from the tech sector. Now they’re Youtubing all over the place, with channels within channels. Have they given up, or are they being agile?
A long time ago, before I was chained to This Place, I made The Media Show appointment listening, when it was hosted by Steve Hewlett or, after he died, the former Independent editor Amol Rajan. He swanned in from Fleet Street to make loads of contacts and elbow his way on to University Challenge and the Today programme, and hence his own media empire.
‘Oh Amol, what are you doing son?’ Vish blasted, mid-croissant, a while ago. ‘Nobody wants you to be Steven Bartlett! We’ve already got one of them, and nobody wants to work for him. Have you seen how often he puts up job ads? You’re easier to work with, Al!’
Vish rolled his eyes when I said I was very easy to work with. All I want is coffee and competence, in that order. ‘How many more people,’ I said when Vish set down that day’s second coffee, ‘are going to buy a microphone, hire two camera operators, build a brand and tell us to follow it? And don’t start, Em, because I’m not doing a podcast.’
‘You’re 2000 and late, Al,’ Em said, cruelly but fairly. ‘Stick to the blog. And don’t put that in!’
Sorry, Em. It’s in. Anyway, the BBC and its future. You know how WH Smith is in the process of shuttering all its shops because books, magazines and newspapers are all nineteenth century products? That, I am afraid, is where the BBC is in 2026, except they’re also the go-to place for news of nuclear disasters, airspace closures and the forthcoming AI-pocalypse!
‘Are we going to do another pros and cons list, Al?’ Vish sighed.
‘Can you think of anything better to do?’
He could: getting down to inbox zero, drafting contributions to Westminster Hall debates, trying to Jenga my diary in this tricky Christmas season where all must have public appearances. But he chose the best option.
‘Right!’ I started, starting a new sheet on my tablet to prepare for a brainstorm.
‘Right,’ Vish and Em said in unison.
There was only one place to start: the recent BBC commercial that got Romesh Ranganathan to ask ‘What has the BBC ever done for me?’ My answer is helped by a man on the inside, the great Phil Tinline, a radio producer-turned-author and commentator who was actually on the BBC last week talking about his very readable book on the USA, Ghosts of Iron Mountain. Tinline wrote a piece in the New Statesman recently that astutely began by reminding readers of an advert that John Cleese fronted in 1985, who asked license-fee payers ‘what has the BBC ever given us?’
Tinline writes that even though he worked on documentaries for radio, he ‘always felt part of a much bigger public culture. The fact that I never had to worry about internet clicks or sales figures meant I could think, and try things, and come up with ideas I’d never have had otherwise.’ Even with the brilliance of pulling together for a common good, ‘there was always the melancholy, long, withdrawing roar: the sound of the BBC’s confidence ebbing away, exacerbated by cuts and scandals and a loss of nerve about its purpose.’
A BBC company man, Tinline realised that the broadcaster were pivoting to podcasts in a world where there were too many podcasts and where social media has ‘no ethics, just metrics’. Good old Auntie Beeb is up against ‘Silicon Valley’s destructive hyper-individualism’, and they are not helping themselves. Here’s his super-duper simile about his final years at the company: ‘It was like watching a management consultant look at an oak tree and say: “The leaves are so beautiful. Can we lose that boring brown trunk underneath?”’
He also thinks the shift from ‘us’ to ‘me’ sums up ‘not only the long-term crisis of confidence at the corporation, but also the way viewers’ priorities have changed over the years. The two slogans embody two fundamentally different ways of thinking about what the BBC is for: the individual, and the public.’ To this end, the BBC, ITV and Channel 4 should work with European broadcasters to pool resources for a sort of kitemarked social media entity, sort of like Eurovision. He notes how the BBC want people who make TVs to include a button to send people to the iPlayer; I think Netflix gets such a button, but won’t SovereignTV want one too, and all the other streamers?
Vish read out some more of Tinline’s piece, sometimes breaking into his David Attenborough impression (everybody’s got one, even you, dear reader): ‘For a century, the BBC has provided a vital means of weaving a shared British culture. Today, however, as media becomes ever more fragmented and personalised, the beleaguered corporation has never seemed less able to do this.
‘We don’t watch the same news at the same time. There’s no more Top of the Pops, or sitcoms everyone can quote. Our shared national viewing is now pretty much The Traitors, the occasional cut-through drama and big sports events. General elections feature televised debates, but these primarily provide clips for social media, which continually turbocharges rumour and disinformation. The shared trust in truth on which mass democracy depends, of which the BBC was long the beating heart, has been bleeding away for years…The BBC has accepted the premise that what matters is giving each individual what they want, in a measurable way.’
And how does the BBC-advertises-itself ad end? ‘There’s a BBC for each of us. Funded by all of us.’ Which other three-letter acronym is funded by the taxpayer and for everyone? Clue: it’s free at the point of use and you don’t even have to pay £180 a year for a TV licence? But, concludes Tinline, ‘if everyone consumes their own version of the BBC on their earpods and phones, there is no broadcasting, just podcasting.’
Vish, Em and I took a simultaneous sip of coffee and each stared at our own fixed point on the office wall. ‘If the BBC had been better, we’d have no need for SovereignTV,’ I said, breaking the silence. ‘Don’t you think it significant that Zia Yusuf has replaced Farage as Question Time’s “on the other hand” panellist?’
‘Question Time is Jeremy Kyle with long words,’ Em said, surprising me. ‘What about the antisemitism? The way 6Music had to be saved by a campaign? Huw Edwards?’
‘Do you know what Jeremy Vine said when Scott Mills was fired? “They’ve sacked Huw Edwards.” ‘They’! Not ‘we’!’
‘Vish, you are very astute. But come now, what has the BBC ever done for you?’
‘The Live Lounge is good,’ he began. ‘The Proms, when they’re not being too niche. Have I Got News For You is still quite funny, most weeks, but it stopped being essential about 15 years ago. The Birkbeck McMillan meme from University Challenge was great. Then The Olympics, Match of the Day, the FA Cup final, Football Focus RIP.’
‘Yes, we get that they’re good at sport,’ Em said.
‘They used to have everything, Em,’ I counselled. ‘But every year another sport tumbles off the Beeb. The skiing’s going next year.’ I was suddenly struck by an idea. ‘Em, can you pump the BBC into Hansard and see what we’ve all said about it? The uglier the better, if you can.’
‘Aye-aye,’ Em said, and came up with some gold that she compiled into this handy Em-I summary (‘do you love Em-I? I love Em-I!!’). She mentioned that certain topics reoccurred annually, including funding, charter renewal, local radio and impartiality, all of which I am grateful to be told about but which I will spare you here for the sake of the word count. Em limited herself to the current parliament, although she could have gone all the way back to the 1920s. I pity the BBC historians who write books about the early years of the Corporation, poring over documents in their archive and in Hansard, but some people get their kicks in certain ways and ours is not to judge.
First, here are some contributions from a Westminster Hall debate of December 2024, in response to an e-petition to abolish the TV licence (if the e-petition gets so many signatures, it must be debated). Liz Jarvis, the Lib Dem MP for Eastleigh, was very good on comparing the BBC’s value for money to Netflix, who in 12 years had doubled the premium subscription. ‘Consider the impact on a young person from a low-income household who might discover a passion for science through a BBC documentary, or be inspired to pursue their dreams by a BBC film. Those transformative experiences would be lost if access were restricted to only those who could afford to pay.’
That’s the same BBC that, ‘for just over £3 a week’, at the time of the debate gave people access to nine TV channels, 39 local radio stations, plus iPlayer and Sounds. Since then, BBC Three has disappeared, BBC Four is now an archive-only channel and many local radio schedules have been amalgamated to save money. ‘In a media landscape dominated by billionaires seeking to engineer narratives that align with their personal interests and agendas, the BBC stands as one of the few institutions committed to impartiality and serving the public,’ says Jarvis, correctly, before invoking Saint – I beg you pardon, Sir, but it’s only a matter of time – David Attenborough.
Now for some things Em found in Hansard during a chamber debate in November 2025, following the resignation of Tim Davie, the DG, and Deborah Turness, the CEO of BBC News. The dispute, over an edited line spoken by an infamously litigious president, is now going to court over allegations of defamation that some would call dictatorial. It provides ammunition to the many, many critics of the BBC, which put up the licence fee £5 in line with inflation in 2025.
First, Culture Secretary Lisa Nandy: ‘The BBC is not just a broadcaster; it is a national institution that belongs to us all. Every day, it tells the story of who we are: the people, places and communities that make up life across the UK. It projects British values, creativity and integrity to the world. It underpins our creative industries, has a footprint in our nations and regions that is unmatched, and is by far the most widely used and trusted source of news in the United Kingdom.
‘At a time when the line between fact and opinion, and between news and polemic, is being dangerously blurred, the BBC stands apart. It is a light on the hill for people here and across the world. Trusted news and high-quality programming are essential to our democratic and cultural life, and all of us in the House should value them, uphold them and fiercely defend them.’
Nigel Huddlestone, the Conservative who shadowed Nandy (past tense as he’s since been replaced), said that the BBC ‘also has a charter obligation of impartiality, and too many examples have come to light of bias…particularly in relation to its news and current affairs output. It has often strayed far from its editorial guidelines, including in its coverage of trans rights, its selective push notifications of news, in the Gaza documentary, in the output of the Arabic news service, and in its reliance on stats provided by Hamas. All those things speak to bias at the BBC.’
And here’s Oliver Dowden, former Deputy of the Conservative Party: ‘People who work for it have an overwhelmingly metropolitan outlook and obsess about issues such as Black Lives Matter and Palestine in a way that suburban and provincial England does not obsess. Moreover, my constituents [in Hertsmere, just north of London] are sick of waiting for the lecture from the BBC in output such as drama. That is the case from other broadcasters, but the difference with the BBC is that my constituents pay for it…Many people feel that it represents half the United Kingdom and not the other half.’ Which half is Dowden considering here? Perhaps the one that used to vote for his party.
Now three Labour MPs, starting with Jonathan Brash, who asked whether it was acceptable for members ‘who are paid by the BBC’s commercial rivals…to use their status as an MP to mount sustained and frenzied attacks that have only one aim: to destroy this national institution’. One of them, in fact, was ‘probably in make-up as we speak’, a jibe at the Reform UK leader. Pamela Nash asked whether attacks on the BBC from all sides showed how ‘it continues to make every effort to maintain balance in a world of increasingly polarised and divisive media’.
Finally Pam Cox, whose husband was a BBC reporter in Vietnam and Myanmar, said she ‘saw for myself how he and the BBC worked very hard for truth…alongside extraordinarily brave local journalists who sought to expand public broadcasting under a military dictatorship’. Such reporting was ‘one of our strongest defences against disinformation, both at home and abroad’, which is spot on.
Rupert Lowe, the ex-Reform UK MP who is not a fan of the BBC at all, thinks ‘now is the time to responsibly defund this monopoly’. Members of the Other Place also discussed the fallout. They included two former Directors-General (‘I think that’s the plural,’ wrote Em) and Baroness Floella Benjamin, the legendary CBBC presenter. ‘My Lords, the children’s BBC, especially CBeebies, is highly trusted. Parents feel safe and confident for their children to watch it. The content is mostly homegrown and culturally relevant, so that our children grow up understanding their world.
‘We need to do everything in our power to protect this last bastion of high-quality content, as children migrate to unregulated online platforms. I fear for the future of this high-quality children’s content if the BBC is weakened. How are the Government going to ensure that we do not abandon children, and maintain a robust BBC?’
John Birt, former Director-General, said that the BBC ‘is a crucible for our best writers, funniest humourists, scientists, naturalists and historians, for every aspect of our culture’ but sometimes ‘mistakes are made’ (classic passive voice construction). The other ex-DG, Tony Hall, denied any ‘institutional bias within the BBC. There are hard-working journalists seeking after the truth and sometimes they get it wrong.’
One such example had happened earlier in 2025, with the BBC criticised for screening the anti-Israel, pro-Palestine sloganeering of Bob Vylan at Glastonbury. Stuart Andrew, the Shadow Culture Secretary, responded to the government. ‘Let me be clear: a national broadcaster funded by licence payers must adhere to the highest standards of impartiality, responsibility, and commitment to social cohesion. I hope we can all agree that in this instance it has failed profoundly.
‘Free speech and political activism are the sign of a healthy democracy. They are essential to it, but when someone crosses the line to incitement to violence, there must be a consequence…This incident also raises fundamental questions about the BBC’s institutional culture. This is a broadcaster that has time and again given airtime to representatives and supporters of Hamas, while refusing to clearly identify the group as what it is: a terrorist organisation.’ Nobody’s perfect, as Billy Wilder once wrote.
A few weeks beforehand there was a Westminster Hall debate on funding the BBC World Service, discussing the Corporation’s soft power as an agent (in the best way!) of the state, as it had been during the latter days of Empire. Labour MP Peter Prinsley kicked off the debate thus: ‘There are few institutions in the world that so consistently live up to the values we claim to cherish – truth, independence and freedom – as does the BBC World Service.
‘Together with the royal family, the BBC is one of a tiny handful of British brands known by billions worldwide; and not just known, but trusted. It broadcasts in 43 languages to 400 million people a week, bringing impartial news to some of the most dangerous and controlled places on Earth. It is a beacon for those who are denied the right to free expression, and a trusted voice in a world increasingly awash with propaganda, intimidation and disinformation. It certainly strengthens our hand when we deal with tyrants worldwide.’ All at the cost of £366m per annum.
Finally, Em uncovered two more things from Lisa Nandy, Culture Secretary, in June 2026. ‘The BBC is one of our most important national institutions,’ Nandy said. ‘For all the challenges that the BBC has faced, it remains the most trusted source of news in this country, and one of the most trusted sources of news across the world. I recognise that the BBC has had some serious challenges to deal with, and has had to make some difficult decisions, but this Government are determined to support its efforts by ensuring that it is adequately funded.’
In 2027, the Royal Charter that grants the BBC a broadcasting licence is up for debate, and Nandy has already said it will be the last one in the present form, putting them ‘on a permanent charter, so that it exists in perpetuity for all of us, forever’. And ever, amen. Thanks be to Attenborough.